Excellent treat, once our 4mo GSD figured out what they were (different consistency than he was used to, like a cheetoh) he loved them and I really think I can tell the difference in his stool as well between these treats and the garbage bag milk bone treats. He loves then and I don't feel bad giving them to him. Love all the training and the forums as well. If you don't already go to Team Dog and subscribe, Mike is a great teacher.
My English Bulldog loves his treats. After I gave him the first one he stood on his hind legs begging for another one. High praise coming from my dog.
I can't say much more than my dog loves these things. I'm working with a nine year old Frenchie without much prior training. These treats get and hold his attention. They've been indispensable in getting consistent engagement from this animal. And the ingredients are awesome. My recommendation: offer bigger bags!!
Team Dog Beef Bites Dog Treats Freeze-Dried - 5.4 oz